gallery

 

 

modsoc's

A-Z

 

 

feature of the month

 

This section comes to you straight from the ‘front line’ of the built environment highlighting the ever changing fortunes of 20th century Manchester buildings both great and small, tracing their progress from flavour of the month, to unloved and neglected, and finally, inevitably to the implacable wrath of the bulldozer.

 

nb - readers of a sensitive nature might wish to look away now & shield their eyes from explicit scenes of mindless violence against helpless architectural rarities...

 

BBC New Broadcasting House

November 2011

 

Oxford Road, Manchester

And so, the BBC leaves its Manchester base for Salford and turns off the studio lights for the very last time. Opened by Prime Minister James Callaghan in June 1976, the building will be decommissioned after North West Tonight in the last week of November 2011, and the last remaining team will join 1700 other BBC staff at Media City UK.

After compulsory purchase orders were approved for the site in 1967, planning began and after abandoning designs by an external architect, design work was completed the BBC's Architectural and Civil Engineering Department, with a completion date of 1975.

The BBC has sold the premises to Reality Estates for an undisclosed fee. Reality Estates won the bid from a shortlist including the likes of Bruntwood and Downing. Reality Estates also own Gateway House on Piccadilly Station Approach and the former Manchester Abattoir in Newton Heath.

Perhaps unloved by many due to its uncompromising concrete facade, possibly one of the most impressive features is the radio studio built to house the Northern Symphony Orchestra, later known as the BBC Philharmonic, alas this huge studio is now silent but the band plays on.. in Salford.

 

APRIL SPECIAL FEATURE -

 

Manchester’s cenotaph to be moved to make way for metrolink tram line...

 

this provocative headline caught our eye in the MEN recently and from the reaction of the local press and its readers it seems we weren’t alone in expressing some worries about this latest upheaval both for the memorial itself and the future of the whole of St Peters Square, currently undergoing major redevelopment. a flurry of correspondence between ourselves and the twentieth century society caseworker confirmed that this latest development is definitely one they will be keeping under scrutiny.

 

the Cenotaph, designed by Edward Lutyens, he of the magnificent former Midland Bank on King St (also currently under refurbishment) is almost identical to his Cenotaph in London's Whitehall, and alongside the elegant Modernist masterpieces of E Vincent Harris, and the City Architect LC Howitt’s Garden of Remembrance, forms the centrepiece to perhaps the city’s most important civic and sacred twentieth century landscapes.

 

the current state of play, following a closed committee meeting in March on controversial proposals to squeeze the cenotaph into the space currently occupied by the sadly neglected Peace Gardens, hints that no final decision will be made until some public consultation has been provided for. yet just when and how this consultation will take place has yet to be made clear.

 

just last summer the redevelopment of St Peters Square was hailed as the creation of a a world-class public space for its revamped Central Library and Town Hall Extension and none of the 5 shortlisted plans on display to the public for comment and feedback included moving the cenotaph. in fact its press release assured us that ‘The cenotaph will not be affected by the redesign of the square and will remain in its current position”

 

Terry Wykes’ Public Sculpture of Greater Manchester thought the calamitous addition of a tram stop back in 1992 was ‘a planning decision that suggested contempt rather than carelessness.’ 20 years on there is a unique window of opportunity to put that right rather than further compromise this significant landscape any further....

 

We are most grateful to Aidan Turner Bishop of the C20 NW group for his eloquent and beautiful Paean to the Cenotaph and its complex cultural, symbolic and national significance, which can be read this month on our April Icon of the Month Page

 

...........................................................................

 

 

THOROUGHLY MODERNIST HEROINES – A MARCH CENTENARY SPECIAL!

a true collaboration from start to finish, the Modernist Heroines project sprang from an ongoing conversation here in the MMS office about the peculiar position of women in Modernism – you know, those ‘girls’ in the Bauhaus, forbidden to take architecture and relegated to more ‘suitable’ positions in the weaving room – and the ones who occasionally broke into the men’s room such as Charlotte Perriand and Eileen Gray.

women like these were pivotal to the Modern Movement but exotically international and far from Manchester. Nearer to home were women influencing the twentieth century city or taking the lead in design, architecture and planning? Manchester was certainly at the epicentre of the women’s movement in the nineteenth and early twentieth century and their tales of bravery, struggle and daring-do are the stuff of legend. But what happened next?

in the new century Manchester was at the forefront of science, engineering and physics, leading the world in aeronautics, atomic science and computing – our universities combined have produced 25 Nobel Laureates – surely a sector ripe for bright young women eager to look under the test tube or take up the theodolite? Or were they hearing what Corbusier reputedly said to Perriand when he dismissed her initial application with a terse ‘we don’t embroider cushions here’...?

after the Pankhursts, the suffragettes and the heady Votes for Women era, how were women really progressing? IWD’s centenary celebrations seemed the perfect opportunity to find out just what the next generation of women got up to in our own back yard. We asked The LRM (Loiterers Resistance Movement) and The Shrieking Violet to help us put something interesting together and invited women to get involved.

the result is a special edition of the Shrieking Violet fanzine launching for IWD on 8 March; a collection of essays, interviews, artworks and events which aim to commemorate the achievements of just ten North West women spanning the fields of invention, aviation, media, science, design and architecture throughout the twentieth century and into the twenty first.

this month we are dedicating our features of the month to all those modernist heroines past and present be they unsung or rightly celebrated!....enjoy!

PS. to discover more heroines download a printable pdf at the Shrieking Violet blogspot.

So, where better to kick off than with local girl Sadie Speight, described as a key figure in the dissemination of modernism in Britain, yet still nowhere near as recognised as she should be....

tucked away in the bibliographical note to Clare Hartwell and Terry Wyke’s (Eds.) Making Manchester, an illustrated volume of essays on the history of architecture of Manchester and the region, 2007, is an intriguing allusion to the rarity of research undertaken into the careers of that elusive creature – the modernist female architect.

 

it says ‘no study exists of women’s painfully slow advance in the profession in the region in the last century. Indeed with the possible exception of designer Sadie Speight, who studied at the Manchester School of Architecture in the 20’s, there appears to be little published research.’

 

Intrigued by the discovery (for me at least) of another heroine to add to our collection, a little digging around soon rewarded with the following snippets of tantalisinginformation....

 

Sadie Speight was born in Lancashire in 1906. She and her equally bright sister Kathleen were educated at St Mary's and St Anne's, Abbots Bromley, and Manchester University, in the School of Architecture.

 

A bright star and rare female in the department, she graduated in 1929 with first class honours, and the accolades and scholarships didn’t end there - a Prix de Rome finalist, she also won the Zimmern Travelling Fellowship which gave her further study abroad, and in 1930 she was awarded the RIBA's silver medal and elected an associate. In 1932 she held the Faulkner Fellowship and the year following gained her Masters degree.

In the 1930's, Sadie Speight and her husband, Leslie Martin wrote two important design books, Everyday Things, 1931, and The Flat Book, 1939. Married in 1935, Martin and Speight were also architectural partners. They designed a fresh, user friendly expandable nursery in timber unit construction, in Northwich, Cheshire, and a series of three modern houses in the North of England. They were also part of an influential ‘set’ of artists and sculptors, Herbert Read's 'gentle nest of Artists'. Work had begun on Circle, a manifesto of Constructivist art, with Leslie Martin as joint editor with Naum Gabo and Ben Nicholson – The Flat Book was commissioned by Read. There seemed to be no stopping them....

after ww2 Martin forged ahead in the public sphere, whilst Sadie remained in private practice, designing for both industrial production and commercial interiors, contributing to the Festival of Britain and writing for the Architectural Review. Like many in the post war period, she was a versatile polyglot, her output incredibly varied stretching to interior design, shop-window displays as well as her architectural projects- keen to experiment and make design available to a mass market. The Council of Industrial Design was set up to promote well-designed goods and she became a founder member of its Design Research Unit, formed to make designer skills available to industry - her work for them, including kettles, electric irons and textiles, was typically ahead of its time.

On top of all this, much of her energies were injected into the outstanding career of her husband Sir Leslie Martin, the architect of the Festival Hall and from 1956 to 1972 Professor of Architecture at Cambridge, and her own notable achievements seem to have suffered from the still pervasive truism ‘behind every great man...’, making her all but forgotten to history except as Lady Martin, the other half of a great architect!

thankfully her career has become the focus of new research led by the Women and Built Space research group at the University of Brighton who have discovered evidence of her influence and significance in this most male dominated field, including her long professional correspondence with that most pernickety of architectural historians Sir Nikolas Pevsner. Jill Seddon, a key figure in this research project, writes that Speight is ‘a key figure in the dissemination of modernism in Britain and early exponent of the needs of the consumer of design, whose work until now has received little critical attention’

it surely won’t be long before the name Sadie Speight is once again back in the official canon where it belongs, rather than languishing in semi obscurity and out of the shadow of her illustrious other half..

sadie speight - modernist heroine - mar 2011

Sadie Speight, aka Lady Sarah Martin, 1906 - 1992.

.........................................................................................

January features - Richard Brook explores 2 hidden chapels....

 

after december’s special investigations from Mr Rhead about the dastardly disappearance of notable public sculptures right under our very eyes, we decided to bring in the new year with the rediscovery of some hidden gems, right under our very noses!

these hot off the press reports come from our intrepid field explorer Richard Brook – thanks to him for the text, images and gorgeous architectural drawings.

plus, as a special one off treat, no RIP! this month it’s all about the Good News.....so settle down as Field Agent Brook reveals the story of two hidden chapels -

 

January features - Richard Brook explores 2 hidden chapels....

 

There are few buildings of the twentieth century that escape the curious eye of the MMS and their field agents, but occasionally from behind a wall or tucked away in some private realm a covert artefact reveals itself. One of the main stakeholders in land to the south of the city is the University and between the old institutions and the more recent pretenders there is a wealth of modern architecture to behold.

 

The expansion of the universities following the Robbin’s Report of 1963 resulted in the commission of Wilson Womersley to masterplan the education precinct and manage the expansion of the Polytechnic, UMIST, the University and the siting of the new RNCM. An accelerated building programme rapidly changed the face of Oxford Road as the works of Fairhurst, Cruickshank & Seward, BDP and Wilson Womersley themselves filled the gaps left by slum clearance and advanced to the projected line of the proposed ring and radial road system of the 1945 Plan and subsequent SELNEC highway study of 1962. Of course, these buildings are readily visible and accessible to those with a bent for architectural voyeurism as well as being documented in the familiar reference sources. Alongside the growth in estate for study there was a demand for new accommodation and the existing residences in the established and leafy part of Victoria Park, between Wilmslow Road and Upper Brook Street, were ready for investment and improvement.

 

Two of the new halls of residence were also set to include Church of England chapels as part of their development, Hulme Hall and St. Amselm’s Hall. In each case the funding was to come from the CofE Central Board of Finance in London and was not a part of the University’s commission.

 

 - the story continues on our marvellous modernist icons page.......

 

.......................................................................................................................................

 

 

 

the perils of post war public sculpture....Mr Rhead investigates!

 

Here at the Manchester Modernist Society we do like a good bit of public art and we were heartened therefore to see two stories recently about two separate pieces of public art that then got us thinking about other pieces around and about.

 

The first story was concerning a piece called Man and Technic which was in the grounds of the former Brookway High School in Wythenshawe.  Designed by Mitzi Cuncliffe it had been badly treated over the years and when it was announced the school was being rebuilt and 'rebranded' as The Manchester Health Academy our hearts sank. However the piece has been retained and given pride of place outside the front entrance. Go down and see it if you get the chance.

 

The other story was concerning a brand new work erected in memory of the late Andy Robson, a well respected Manchester architect, in Spinningfields. Whilst any new public art is to welcomed it stirred us into remembering other once proudly erected pieces of public sculpture that all too often disappear without trace from the city.

 

Mr Eddy Rhead investigates the sorry tale of missing post war sculptures.....

 

totem, Frank Belsky

Arndale Centre, 1977 - 1987

 

Another striking piece of public art we know for certain has gone forever is Totem by Franta Belsky which dominated the Arndale Centre for just 10 short years. Installed in 1977, in the first phase of the Arndale Centre, Totem was 9.5 metres high and made of glass reinforced resin. It sat in a terrazzo base filled with water and consisted of four distinct but physically joined elements, each representing  an aspect of the region’s history and economy. The original intention was to allow water to fall over the whole of the sculpture but the developers rejected the idea. It provided a very distinctive feature to an otherwise architecturally bland Arndale Centre. As a young Modernista who misspent his youth hanging around the Arndale up to no good, this writer found the scale and form more than a little intimidating but which left a lasting impression never the less.

 

Franta Belsky was not only able to produce abstract pieces like Totem, other works can be found in Stevenage New Town and at The Shell Centre on the South Bank, but he was very much in demand for his portraiture statues and busts - one of his statues stands in Trafalgar Square. Belsky was well regarded and Totem won a medal from the Royal Society of British Sculptors, an enlarged replica of the medal was fixed to the base. This regard was clearly not shared by the owners of the Arndale who removed the piece when they redeveloped the shopping centre in 1987. The Arndale entered a new phase where seating for customers is not even provided never mind any aesthetic or cultural stimulus. Totem, it is presumed, has been destroyed.

 

RIP - File under lost modernism - dec 2010

 

images and information on this months public sculpture

feature is indebted to the following publication - 

 

Public Sculpture of Greater Manchester (Public Sculpture of Britain) [Paperback]

Terry Wyke Liverpool University Press

..........................................................................................................................................

manchester's beautiful beton brutes...

in september’s feature of the month, we raised the thorny issue of brutalism and its overwhelming association with the mass social housing project of the post war era – the two have almost become synonymous (at least to its detractors), calling to mind the fortress-like estates of robin hood gardens and thamesmead in London or nearer to home the hulme crescents and fort ardwick.

the term itself certainly doesn’t help matters, suggesting something hard and uncompromising, ugly or inhumane, an architecture that sacrificed aesthetics to principles or theory. yet as we saw in the September feature its original intentions were anything but - derived from Le Corbusier's term 'béton brut', it just meant raw concrete. New Brutalism in its early years (1950's in the UK) was a design philosophy, not a style; a philosophy aiming to create an aesthetic based on the exposure of a building’s components: its frame, skin and service systems. it then rapidly evolved as a general reference to buildings that possessed a rough concrete finish on a fortress-like mass or bulk structure, which in turn came to evoke almost universal criticism and contempt.

yet its tough, uncompromising truth to materials and lack of window dressing is what makes it uniquely indigenous – particularly british if you like, a fittingly home spun take on the European template in the tradition of our brochs, keeps and castles – all arrow slits and impregnability as befits our island mentality and unforgiving climate - overtaking the previous softer era of Scandinavian inspired humanistic modernism.

away from the domestic environment however these attributes have been rather more positively received, even dare we say it, admired? so this month we take a peep at three classic manchester bunkers, buildings that even the most critical architectural tomes have heaped with praise for their practicality, elegance and truth to materials, each notable for their wealth of texture, attention to detail and geniality once past the tough carapace.

the lesson? please don’t judge this increasingly at risk period by its cover. it’s time to take a closer look and rediscover the beauty in our shy beton bruts...

 

*****ps. dont worry - this building isnt dead, far from it, but the departure of the bank certainly resulted in the demise of its beautiful modernist ground floor banking hall - we just like to shock sometimes. it clarifies the mind....

 

District Bank/Nat west, 55 King Street,

Casson, Condor & partners 1966-9


if there is a deluxe version of beton brut then this bold beauty is it - in its time this  was the most expensive building in Manchester, costing over £12 million, with Sir Hugh Casson as architect, who had laid out the Festival of Britain in London in 1951. he was to become President of the Royal Academy.

 

dark and dignified, it was purposely built in black stone to resist the notorious Manchester soot which covered virtually all the city’s buildings pre the clean air act and to give an extra gravitas to its importance as the bank's northern headquarters, a prodigious enterprise overseeing 700 branches throughout the northwest of England. 

 

an all-concrete shell (constructed in situ with steel reinforcement) with transfer beams and external voids for window apertures, its rough hand-tooled vertically ribbed dark cladding of Swedish granite is opulent yet refined - an elegant deference to its setting amongst such elite company as lutyens midland bank, cockeralls grade I Listed bank of England and ship canal house. though only 6 floors in height – it cleverly integrated 3 extra floors beneath ground level, including vaults below the rock table - it does seem to loom larger now that the other buildings around it have been cleaned up. perhaps this is also due to the tragic loss of its stark white modernist ground floor banking hall designed to give relief to the brooding broch-like exterior. to our mind, the late 90’s remodelling into small retail units has broken the original thoughtfulness and ingenuity of design. cube’s impeccable city tours puts it more strongly

 

‘The original smooth white Modernist banking hall, intended to contrast with the fortress like exterior has been destroyed in the building’s recent retail conversion.’

 

lets conclude with the technical admiration of the excellent Manchester architecture guide...

‘it demonstrates a skilled and inventive architectural interpretation of the shift away from international modernism. the sheer black ribbed granite facade employs a language of highly abstracted traditional forms. fortress like it terminates in a quasi-mansard roof although the flush-set glazing is far from traditional. the gaunt verticality of the exterior contrasts with the smooth white marble-lined horizontality of the banking hall (now entirely removed - the building's ground floor is now a small retail shopping complex) externally the building defines one edge a sheltered plaza over a parking deck’. (Manchester architecture guide 1999, canniffe and Jeffries).

not RIP but needlessly messed about with!

..........................................................................................................................................

 

 

SIGNS OF THE TIMES - whats in a name?

 

this month we investigate the stories behind three Manchester landmarks famous as much for their typefaces  - evocative messages in font – as for their architectural significance, their individual trials and tribulations revealing much about changing attitudes and times.

 

in another impassioned declaration of the State of Mancunia one classic glass sixties gem similarly confirmed its allegiance to the city for over 40 years, evoking the spirit of Modern Manchester long before the likes of Peter Saville graced us with their postmodern branding. Manchester House presided over the city with its bold modernist typeface, brazening it out with a dash of much needed colour no matter how overcast the sky or resolutely grey the weather.

 

long earmarked for demolition after being acquired for the Spinningfields redevelopment of the old civic square, it somehow managed to survive, a lone Mancunian presence in an otherwise anonymous corporate world. when it was announced earlier this year that it was to be retained and refurbished anchored by the city’s first waitrose, we knew the writing was on the wall for this stalwart guardian of a lost modernist aspiration.

built by those doyens of Manchester modernism Leach Rhodes Walker it was the last word in innovation and up to the minute engineering. Manchester house was as cutting edge as it got, literally stopping traffic with its in situ construction. moreover dennis sharp included it in his 1968 city vistas series –

 

Manchester House, Bridge St

Leach Rhodes Walker, 1965-2010

 

built as the Scottish Life House, but soon adopting a more local moniker, Manchester House is one of the last surviving monuments  to the fallen civic aspirations of its age, partially realised in what is now Spinningfields on the River Irwell. terminating the Processional Way complex of Crown and Cumberland Square, its new name spelt out in sky blue boldly proclaimed the living embodiment of the 1945 Manchester Plan, its very construction an innovation.

 

Leach Rhodes Walker introduced new techniques here, making it a sixties cause celeb hitting the headlines and regularly stopping traffic whilst being put together piece by piece, constructed in in situ concrete in a continuous casting process by means of a climbing  shutter. the floor slabs were then all cast on top of one another at ground level and lifted by jacks around the core into their eventual position, its central core containing a scissor staircase and services. as sharp adds dryly, these measures saved considerable time and expense.

 

the finished block took the form of a square 8 storey tower over a 2 story podium which in its time has been home to the Manchester building society, the fabulous shimla pinks and the arts council north west. it also featured in the opening sequence of the film version of the Manchester sitcom The Lovers, the entire scene epitomising the groovy new swinging sixties city with its Georgie Best boutique, mini skirted dolly birds and lunch time discotheques. Manchester had never had it so good....

a pity then that this symbol of post war reconstruction, built by one of the city’s finest architectural firms in the new idiom, couldn’t remain. after all the new waitrose only takes up a quarter of the ground floor space and has its fascia demurely  written above its lintel. so why remove the signage at all – cant it remain Manchester house, or is a new name, one less evocative and emotive in the pipeline?

perhaps a blank space is a fitting metaphor for the new homogenous spinningfields, filled with international banks and worldwide brands however luxury, an identikit outdoor mall that could be anywhere  – to this old cynic it certainly speaks volumes....

 

Manchester House, RIP, 2010

............................................................................................................................................

 

 

the big experiment - the rise and fall of modernist housing

 

what factors make the barbican a signifier of urban sophistication but fort ardwick a bye-word for disaster? in Manchester the debate is still dominated by the spectral presence of the Hulme Crescents, fort ardwick and beswick, but this month we take a closer look at sheffield's park hill and compare its changing fortunes with a couple of less well known examples back here in our own city. what heady alchemy between design and planning, quality of building materials, local amenities and community involvement is required for housing to become home?

Kennet House, Smedley Point, Cheetham/Crumpsall.

1933-5, RAH Livett Manchester corporation

 

walk around Chime Bank today where smedley lane meets woodlands rd in lower crumpsall and you will find a typical mix of low rise barratt style houses, gardens and cul de sacs; respectable modern manchester. but for more than 40 years this was the site of one of the city’s earliest post-1918 attempts at continental style civic flats, a radical solution to a nationwide crisis of overcrowded victorian terraces with few basic amenities – most were lacking internal bathrooms or toilets let alone gardens or access to green space and playgrounds.

in the midst of a global depression, a glut of papers by planners, local authorities and government emphasised an urgent need to abolish slums, rebuild cities and improve conditions for the working population, which culminated in the 1930 Housing & Slum Clearance Act. always keen to make a bold statement, manchester responded with a state of the art decotastic design overlooking the irk, totally against the general trend for garden suburbs such as wythenshawe and a housing policy which had favoured the cottage style homes built in withington, chorltonville and blackley.

Davies and Fielding in the book Workers’ Worlds point out that for some, flats were seen as the key ‘to solving housing problems in a modern, scientifically planned and communal fashion’. kennet house represented ‘Manchester’s lead to Europe’ and a forward thinking ‘continental’ style, and the press went into rhapsodies over its structural beauty and fitted cupboards, which were ‘a housewife’s delight’. the book also includes much interesting insight into the role, imput and criticisms made by the womens advisory committee on the designs and practicalities of both the new cottage homes and the ultra modern flats. then as now too few were listened to, as many were distinctly ‘unawed’ by certain aspects of either solution....!

Kennet House and the neighbouring Woodlands estate were based on the style of the Queen Mary and other 1930’s ocean liners and the few images available amply illustrate its innovative yet elegant design, dominating the landscape for all the world as if the cunard had run aground on the banks for the river irk! though traditionally made from brick, it simulated the continental craze for sleek concrete with a cement render. Inside, apartments were suitably high spec with their own bathrooms and toilets and a balcony off the kitchen/scullery; whilst communal luxury touches included its own dance hall and billiard room for the inhabitants, plus a laundry room on the top floor. In the grounds there were shops either side of the entrance – including a butchers, grocers, paper shop, deli, barber shop and ironmongers – whilst the wrap-around structure harboured landscaped gardens and play areas for all to enjoy. It even had its own air raid shelters in the second world war.

there is a frustrating lack of information in the usual architectural press but when the ever reliable dennis sharp gives it a brief inclusion in his 1968 City Buildings Manchester guide, then you can be sure it was something remarkable –

 

a continuous form of development 600ft in length, designed as an oval with service access and play space internally. it comprises 181 dwellings. this development is located against a hill and expresses this topography by the building stepping down from 5 storeys to 2. it is arranged symmetrically on its long axis (apart from the main entrance) despite the fact that its eastern side overlooks the Irk valley. the construction is of load bearing brickwork and in common with other designs of this era anticipates a concrete frame structure in its external appearance.

 

despite this grand start and the fond memories of many who lived there over the years, by the 60’s and 70’s the flats had fallen into disrepair and were demolished in 1978.

nowadays apart from the anecdotes littered across the internet there’s no physical trace of manchester’s first venture into continental living, with its glamorous homes ‘fit for heroes’....

 Kennet House, RIP, 1978

.........................................................................................................................................

Here comes summer - august bank holiday special!

yes, its the summmer and we are feeling just too lazy to sit in the library looking up obscure details about the modernist built environment...

what would the mms have been doing in the modernist city during those legendary long hot summers of the 1960's & 70's. well if we werent at belle vue zoo its quite likely we would have been at an outdoor lido or paddling pool. failing that we might have taken to the boating lake and gone for a bit of  a row amongst the swans and the ducks.

now long gone, here's a short photo homage to the great local park. what fun they were.....

chorlton park paddling pool 1960

heaton park boating lake early 60's

wythenshawe paddling pool

splashing about at the park, RIP!

........................................................................................................................................

 

for july we are highlighting the battles facing those much maligned monuments from the post war period, an era beseiged by a pincer movement of bulldozers, public indifference and an often outright aggressive press, with the story of three locals battling the forces of antipathy.... 

 

 

EAGLE STAR HOUSE, 54-70 Mosley Street,

CRUIKSHANK & SEWARD, 1973 -2005

 

Built originally for Royal London Assurance, this large glass and concrete block never stood much of a chance, replacing as it did the much loved 1841 Milne Building that had received the highest praise from Pevsner in his Buildings of England, declaring it ‘the most startling warehouse of Manchester.’ hardly a good introduction for any successor, even such an elegant one by the renowned Manchester firm Cruikshank and Seward.

No surprise then that less than 30 years later it was the recipient of wholesale condemnation bordering on savagery, described as‘the worst blight on the street’ and a ‘decaying hulk providing an unwelcome blemish on a modern city seeking inward investment’ in various local press. The city council couldnt get rid of it fast enough, presumably fearing that it alone stood in the way of manchester’s commercial and cultural rebirth, its position near the city gallery’s expensive new extension a veritable affront!

The printed word tends to take on the tenor of orthodoxy and the erudite considerations over at the ever reliable archisnaps were presumably drowned out by the scorn of the MEN and the property press on the one hand and the weight of pevsner on the other. a pity because this reading paints a distinctly different picture -

Incorporating what must be one of the last built elements of Manchester’s proposed elevated city centre pedestrian deck Eagle Star House contrasts with the scale and verticality of its built context. A level of deck sits above street shop frontage, above which are three storeys of horizontally expressed offices and a rooftop penthouse. End elevations express the section of the scheme with circulation space being articulated by a full height cleft running from deck level upwards. Clad in smooth Portland stone its Modernist credentials are emphasised with a Corbusian stair meeting the street corner at the northern end of the building.

despite this plucky defence it was eventually demolished for the entirely dreary cobbett house, a particularly pointless rebuild that appears to be trying so hard to be a pastiche of a modernist building that we might as well have been bold enough to keep the original. we end with its own tepid boast:

The building provides a harmonious synthesis of contemporary and traditional to provide a bridge from past/present to future. Contemporary design is mixed with traditional materials such as pre cast concrete and glass to provide a building that will differentiate Cobbetts from its major competitors.

Eagle Star House, cruelly demolished for a palid pretender, 2005

..................................................................

mappa modernista - june 2010

last month the Manchester Modernist Society, in partnership with Taylor Young Architects, introduced an interactive online map of 20th century Manchester’s architectural landmarks, presented as part of MADF2010.

 

with the plight of twentieth century buildings increasingly hitting the press it seems there has never been a better time to appraise the state of the 20th century urban landscape. So here at mms we have embarked on our very own archive of the city, an attempt to create a database and living map of the buildings we lived in, loathed, loved and lost over the past century. An opportunity to reflect on the changes social, economic and cultural carved onto the very fabric of the city and reappraise some of the misunderstandings, failings and controversies surrounding the last 90 years from civic planning aspiration, post war reconstruction, post industrial decline to regeneration via commercially led property development and the resulting impact on our public realm, our skylines and our sense of place.

our mappa modernista  has more in common with the tradition of hand drawn unconventional map than with the standard street map with its proper rules and conventions. and like them our intention is to direct or inspire peregrinations, to stir the imagination and kick start a love affair with the everyday city, a city quickly fading into the past. Forgotten, neglected, demolished or overwhelmed by glitzy newcomers, we almost need x-ray specs to de-clutter the skyline and revisit the modernist city. so peel away the accumulated grime and clutter obscuring the views, & pop on those metaphorical 3 d glasses as we whisk you away on a rollercoaster ride through the 20th century.....

 

BELEAGUERED – revisit the fading landscape of the Modernist city in our guide to treasures long gone or already earmarked for the bulldozer. take a hanky – this mournful homage is not for the fainthearted!

Lest we forget - Bernard House, Cumberland Square, Northcliffe House, the Gaumont Cinema/Rotters on Oxford St, the Maths Tower on Oxford Rd, Mobberley Tower and the beautiful Dalwood Frieze, Loxford Tower, the controversial Hulme Crescents (given the Park Hill Urban Splash treatment they might have become the Barbican of Manchester!); and hanging on by a thread the UBO Offices on Aytoun St, Manchester House, the Old Odeon on Oxford St...

 

RIP - the irreplacable treasures of our twentieth century city.... 

................................................................................................

 

 

modernist month of may - tales from the red phone booth....

 

our saga of the Red phone booth to coincide with the commissioning of our K6 sound installation running at MOSI throughout FutureEverything festival may 2010, draws to a dramatic finish in this section...

 

the k6 reigned unchallenged as the public call-box until the mid1960s, when incessant vandalism and the high cost of maintenance led the Post Office, and subsequently British Telecom, to commission a new generation of more accessible phone boxes. yet its real demise came from within. enter the K8, the young pretender...

 

 

K8, Bruce Martin,

new estates, modernist railway stations, remote windswept spots, 1965 - 1985

THE YOUNG PRETENDER

designed by Bruce Martin, the funky K8 was the first serious challenger to K6. it was used primarily for new sites, around 11000 were installed, replacing earlier models only when they needed relocating or had been damaged beyond repair. the K8 retained a red colour scheme, but in a slightly brighter 'Poppy Red', which went on to be the standard colour across all kiosks. it was sassy, sleek and groovy in a tomorrows world, pans people sort of way, with its full glass panes and streamlined edges. less heritage and altogether more with it, more pop! spot one even today, and it looks modernistic, exciting and futuristic.

 

yet ironically, its relative success was partly due to its K6 inheritance. it took on some aspects of the failed experiment of the K7 (ie. a modern door handle, and full panes of toughened glass on three sides) but remained constructed of cast-iron, greatly adding to its resistance to the UK climate, and with some exceptions the all-over red livery was considered too important to be dispensed with - some K8's in Liverpool and Manchester were painted a distinctive 'Telecom Yellow', as opposed to 'Post Office Red'.and it never completely replaced the old war horse; K6 and K8 survived together into the 1980's, when the death knell for both were sounded with the arrival of the KX100 series.

 

this marks the real end of our story. the sad story of the red phone booth - they lost their domed roofs. then their red uniforms, and finally even their doors. they were on their way to becoming little more than posts with phones attached when a conservation movement in the 1990s persuaded BT to renovate, and even re-install, some of the old K6s. but this was all too late for the poor K8, now so rare as to be of special interest to the twentieth century society and a focus for one of their at risk campaigns.

 

at the last count only a handful of K8 remain. estimates vary from 12 to 20. if you see one, give us a ring and let us know!

 

ps. a note on Gilbert Scott.

 

Giles Gilbert Scott(1880 –1960) was last in a distinguished line of architects. His grandfather was Sir George Gilbert Scott, who built the Midland Grand Hotel at St Pancras station and the Albert Memorial in Kensington Gardens, whilst his father after a promising start was to languish in asylums and family hideaways for much of his adulthood.

Our Scott is famous for his blending of Gothic tradition with modernism. he was to become a towering figure in 20th century architecture, creating iconic buildings wherever he went. he was RIBA president for its centenary year 1933, completed battersea power station in 1933, the new bodleian library in 1937-40, rebuilt the commons chamber at westminster palace after the 1941 bombing had destroyed it, and designed bankside power station now the magnificent Tate Modern.

yet he is perhaps best-known for his work on Liverpool Cathedral. when the competition for a 'Design for a twentieth century cathedral' was announced in 1902, he was a junior employee at his firm and an inexperienced 21 year old - he had previously only successfully designed a small pipe rack! nevertheless he was one of the five architects selected for the second round of the competition (his employer's designs were rejected) and subsequently went on to win in 1903. it was to become his life’s work which he worked on until his death in 1960; the cathedral was finished in 1978. He is now buried with his wife outside the main entrance to Liverpool Cathedral where a K6 can also be found installed in his honour.

Gilbert Scott & his K Series, RIP, 1980's

..................................................................................................................................

 

 

Mash & Air 40 Chorlton St,

POD, Marc Newson and Harrison Ince , 1996 - 2000.

 

Much to opening fanfare at the tail end of 1996 , Oliver Peyton 's Manchester venture is the corner of Canal st and chorlton Derwent Against the City 's Prevailing Aesthetics of bare girders and industrial chic. INSTEAD the owner of London 's feted Atlantic Bar and Grill and Coast opted for cool Swinging Sixties London with brash orange and lime tones , Circle & porthole reasons . viewed: Either at the time as a refreshing change to What Was Already Becoming a Mancunian cliche , or the ill regarded pretension of a pushy outsider , we pay homage to a long overdue slice of a Short Lived streamlined computer -generated futurism ; nineties chic with joe a hint of 1930 's ocean liner .

peyton Took the restaurant scene by storm in 1994 When He Opened the Atlantic Bar & Grill in London in 1994 and in Mayfair Coast in 1995 . Mash and Air in Manchester Opened in 1996 , Followed by a London Mash Isola in 1998 and in Knightsbridge in 1999. His vibrant 170- seat Atlantic Bar & Grill Was year overnight success with STI art deco makeover , downstairs ballroom and modern British menu, and it Launched the concept of the style bar. ADOPTED Coast meanwhile has more feminine , style and maritime ET Quickly Became Known 've Loved Much For architectural and design savvy 've Loved for catering .

a warehouse conversion at the height of 90's ' gaychester ' right in the Heart of the Village , Mash & Air in Manchester Was Entirely different year to the animals Already Thriving local scene . it one step Derwent Than the Rest , Offering Simply not a bar with dining Tacked drank a ' oven eating and drinking experience level . " Commissioned Peyton Harrison Ince ( Whose portfolio includes Mick Hucknall 's boat and a local chain tampopo ) to work alongside furniture and interior designer Marc Newson and Andrew Martin realized Loved to futuristic ambitions . Designed around a microbrewery , Which pink -through the full height of the building , visible from Portcullis Every level through ITS 's and jaunty porthole , the new design Simply No Paid to heed ITS historic fabric . THE LOWEST level Was a bar , with Two Separate restaurants, Including Mash brewery for casual dining, and a private dining room . Air is situated " Was The Highest level - a ' dining delight ' with sunken booths and panoramic vistas over Manchester ...

By The Turn of the Century all one aim of trail - blazing Loved Opening of the '90s HAD closed . Mash and Air hatches battened down for good STI in 2000 and Still boarded up and empty lies today, barely Remembered It Seems , for all the Hullabaloo in ITS heyday .

here's What They Said in the independent soon after ITS grand opening -

Caroline Stacey

Saturday, 11 January 1997

Just before Christmas , Oliver Peyton , owner of Two London SUCH gaffe - the Atlantic Bar and Grill and Coast - Opened Mash & Air in Manchester. Launches like this do not Happen Every month , OR Events year , here , has yet week after the opening junket, the number of Customers Was Surprisingly sparse . Maybe are harder to impress Mancunian .

After all, There Is civic pride and the tradition of Dissent to Uphold . Though eating and drinking lags well behind , designer bars are Ecu Two year in a city that's Been Transformed by EC Funding . Purpose, barely off the starting block , Mash & Air Quickly impressed me . The design , by Australian Marc Newson , Is in a similar fashion to Sixties - Futurist Coast . And it's beautiful . The wide -windowed Victorian mill, in the middle of the gay quarter , up steps and Entered IS -through glass doors with handles like jumbo orange taps . You arrive in a bar -meets - painted pistachio lime -green ( Even the floor) , and furnished with Duplo for giants .

The name Mash & Air horns from internships in the brewing process , and a central well That Appears To Run From The Top To The Bottom Of The building , visible -through huge porthole , houses painted orange brewing equipment . When it's working, this contemporary looking Brilliantly engine room - a canny tribute to a place That Understands the attraction of manufacturing like no other - Will Own ITS pump out beer . Upstairs , more green and orange Hamid , Is The Mash brewery, with pizzas from a wood - fired oven with a Litany of Scattered Californian ingredients : winter mushroom with honey- roast parsnips , spinach and vegetable chips, for example , and salads and grills.

Air, the restaurant is the top floor , Is All breezy blue, royal and pale . By day, It Was so pure and new light and it appeared Rather ethereal . Any satanic darkness Ever Had the mill has been " air - brushed out Effectively . Mash & Air and panders to a predisposition for designer tags, with nickable " mashtrays " and a Bill That Comes in a blue envelope with "the damage "written on it . Even if it Were not for the food, Mash & Air would Still Be a triumph .

visit for more pictures ince harrison here.

 

 

RIP - Mash & Air - 2000

.................................................. .................................................. .........

 

March - April 2010

Special Odeon

 

This month in Light of the narrow window of opportunity to put pressure on the planning department to Reconsider Proposed demolition of the Long the Odeon Cinema on Oxford Rd, we are dedicating o March - April Features of the Month to the sorry story of this fine picture palace.

 

RIP - GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN ~

 

Back in January 2010 in Our tribute to the city 's Picture Palaces , we have featured the Odeon o At Risk Gem of the Month Little Imagining it Might Reach the critical list in Three short months ! Sadly here we are ....

 

Nb - The planning permission for the demolition of the Odeon , Oxford Street, Manchester is about to run out . The developer Needs To Reapply . We can all put pressure on the planners to reject this. We Now Have a second chance to stop the demolition .

 

You Still Have Time to how the application. We all Need to how the application - online or in writing . Clickhereto go to the application . Many thanks !

 

 

The Odeon Cinema formerly The Paramount Oxford St ,

F Verity and S. Beverley, 1930 - closed September 2004 .

 

The Odeon , now lying stripped bare and hollow , Opened with pomp and ceremony Suitable , all complete with fake art deco stylized flattened pilasters and capitals , on Monday 16 October 1930 as the Paramount Theatre, flashy American import to Oxford St.

More Than Other lavish and luxurious Manchester goings, the Paramount soon Became a Mecca for picturegoers , regularly scooping up all the biggest and best new releases, Especially Those From The Paramount studios , and Being the first to offer innovations have SUCH techicolour and wide screen .

By 1940 howeve Paramount HAD sold off Some of Its UK cinemas to the Odeon circuit and so it Suddenly Became the Odeon , = remaining one of the MOST popular city center cinemas well Into the 1960's , Successfully Complementing STI screenings with occasional live concerts , SUCH as the Beach Boys , Until ITS long , slow demise started " in earnest in the seventies . Like Many Other picture houses, This Was That era saw the successive year Attempt to lure audience, seduced Into home entertainment with the introduction of television, Back Into the cinema . IT WAS twinned in 1973 , triplexed in 1979 , with a furnace Further screens created in 1992 . With adaptation EACH There Was a commensurate loss in the original architectural grandeur and intégrité of the design. By the end of Its Life Resulting the seven screens Were No bigger than Many suburban sitting-rooms and the introduction of the mega complex in the Nineties Were The last straw for the old guard . The cinema was closed in September 2004 due to competition from the AMC Great Northern 16 Which HAD nearby Opened in December 2001 .

Long boarded up, its not yet nominally Assignation , goal in reality it 's a dead man walking ...

The Story Does not End There . Earmarked for demolition and redevelopment Into the inevitable office block with ground floor retail bad at having more gold bar / restaurant uses , a campaign to save the Odeon led by the Cinema Theatre Association erlands and Sweden . Finally in a hotly Contested decision , Français Heritage Dismissed "any last minute Attempts to list the building, standing by Their decision Earlier That the building HAD Been Too Badly mutilated in the course of Its Life To merit it .

For the long and Tragic Saga Of The Attempt to save the Odeon from demolition , read over the emotional and informative trail of comments hand below the posting, Taking us from 2004 up to the present sorry state of affairs , yet try "any of Aidan O'Rourke Manchester 's popular forums for the general mood of Manchester 's Citizens , Many of Whom the ACKNOWLEDGE Difficulties and tensions inherent in nostalgia and Marrying cultural inheritance in contemporary With The Needs Of An Ever Changing urban environment .

***Once again MMS IS Indebted to far more voices and narrator on this topic Learned Than Ourselves . We Have FOLLOWING Shamelessly adapted the illuminating source -

Derek J Southall Magic in the Dark, Cinema Treasures informative website, and David Slack 's reminiscences are 70mm.com .

Over on the Flickr words and gorgeous pictures of woody1969 Highly recommended are .

RIP - Odeon Cinema - September 2004

....................................

 

 

 

Covered Parker Street Bus Terminal

Piccadilly Gardens

 

 

The architecture of transportation terminals Sometimes invisible can prononcer. We use bus , train and ferry stations frequently aim Often When We're tired , in a hurry or stressed. Driving Along motorways transiting Is a similar experience - just going Through Attending but not to WHERE we are. We do not see we look purpose ; and that's a pity Because Some really good buildings - the Architecture of Mobility - can vanish Before We realized just how darned good They Were .

 

Take Piccadilly Bus Station in Parker Street . No, not the bleak windswept collection Of Bus Stop Now order a street -long glass galleria Which ran from Portland Street to Almost Mosley Street. It Opened on December 4 , 1958 , and Lasted Until the Metrolink tram started. It Was a Vast Completely ENCLOSED island , 577ft long and 28ft wide, with An Enquiry Office , a sweet and tobacco store and a first floor staff canteen . Those were the days When a bus crews Expected mug of sweet tea, and IGC has a plate of hot food canteen Between shifts . If They did not get it the TGWU would call a strike.

 

The glass frames Were modular , based on a classic elevation of 1:1.5:4:2 . The ground level frames in 50s Were colored tones of cool blue and lemon yellow. The plan - with a canteen Raised In The center - was with Alternating Symmetrical Levels VARYING one roof module up or down. Subtle stuff. The interior was very light and very carefully with signé route numbers and destinations . You could " shelter , Perhaps smoking a Woodbine or reading the Evening Chronicle, Waiting for the bus to Corporation No. 1 Gatley , in a fine essay of glass modernist modular design - the hub of city transportation network efficient year . Not bad, eh ?

 

<FONT face=